53 comments

Multi Vitamins: So Many Choices

Posted by & filed under Other / Canada.

vitamins

Recently after find­ing out that some of my vit­a­min lev­els are low I started tak­ing a new multi vit­a­min.  I decided on Cen­trum, Cal­trate Plus D, and B12 1000 mcg on the advice of my doc.  While she didn’t tell me what brand of vit­a­min to buy, I was quite over­whelmed with all my options.  I knew I wanted a tablet form rather then a plas­tic cap­sule, but other then that I didn’t know what to get. I stood there for­ever and ended up grab­bing what was on sale. Do you take a multi vit­a­min?   Is there a brand you pre­fer or would recommend?

53 Responses to “Multi Vitamins: So Many Choices”

  1. violin

    Hello there! This is my first com­ment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I gen­uinely enjoy read­ing through your blog posts. Can you rec­om­mend any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the same top­ics? Thank you so much!

  2. Fred

    A lot of peo­ple seem to be try­ing to pass off the infor­ma­tion they received in a 5 minute con­sul­ta­tion with their natur­opath. Rachel cer­tainly has the right idea.

    Kim, I’m not sure what you are try­ing to sug­gest when you say that the vit­a­mins you’re pro­mot­ing are “sol­u­ble”. Every vit­a­min is “sol­u­ble”. Some vit­a­mins are fat-soluble, some are water-soluble. As Rachel said, the water-soluble ones will be excreted in your urine if you take too much, whereas the fat-soluble ones are not (and thus, get­ting too much of a fat-soluble vit­a­min can be dan­ger­ous). Excret­ing excess vit­a­mins in your urine does not sug­gest any­thing about the vit­a­min you are tak­ing other than the fact that you’re get­ting too much. No mul­ti­vi­t­a­min is going to give you energy unless it’s cor­rect­ing a par­tic­u­lar deficiency.

    This is very basic stuff that you would learn in any nutri­tion course. It was taught in the first-year Kine­si­ol­ogy course that I took years ago in Uni­ver­sity, and I had read all about it prior to that. I guess when com­pa­nies are pro­mot­ing over-priced prod­ucts with bogus “advan­tages”, they would sim­ply pre­fer to be the ones giv­ing you their biased “knowl­edge” so you can use that to pro­mote their products.

    Since you all have access to the Inter­net, I would sug­gest doing some of your own research. Search engines are won­der­ful things. The best thing to do is to exam­ine your own diet and deter­mine what nutri­ents you should already be get­ting. Use a site like this one: http://nutritiondata.self.com (it took me about 5 sec­onds to find this site by search­ing for ‘cheese nutri­tion’)
    If all of the food you eat already con­tains these labels, I would sug­gest eat­ing more fruits and veg­eta­bles. Oth­er­wise, fig­ure out what you’re not get­ting enough of and try to cor­rect it through your diet. If you can’t, or you want “insur­ance”, get a cheap mul­ti­vi­t­a­min that has what you’re lack­ing. Most of them are the same, but some, such as the gum­mies, tend to be miss­ing a few things. Of course there are some tai­lored to spe­cific demo­graph­ics as well, and some brands will vary a bit.

    If you feel like you still need to talk to some­one about it, make an appoint­ment with your fam­ily doc­tor and out­line your con­cerns. I would sug­gest a GP over a natur­opath that may very well end up try­ing to SELL you the prod­uct that they rec­om­mend. It may help, but their prod­uct is really no bet­ter than any­thing else out there.

    This all applies to the aver­age indi­vid­ual. If you have a med­ical prob­lem, you should already know what extra steps you need to take.

  3. Sami

    Thanks Stacey and Hadathick­wal­let. Bought the Kir­lkand brand at Costco.

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title="" rel=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>